fish tales market and eatery trip advisor pagefish tales market and eatery facebook

welcome to fish tales market and eatery

Welcome to Fish Tales Market and Eatery in Marathon, a "local’s favorite" where only the freshest local seafood is sold. Fish Tales is a family owned and run full service restaurant, seafood and meat market. George, Jackie and Johnny Eigner, former owners of the popular Grassy Key Dairy Bar, are on site to give their customers that personal touch. All of the seafood in both the market and restaurant is harvested right here in the Florida Keys. From fresh fish, stone crab, lobster and shrimp to hand cut aged steaks we offer a full line of products. We can "cook your catch", or sell you ours.

Stop by and check out our market; offering spices to spreads, rubs to recipes and don’t forget our homemade desserts!

fish tales home page collage

looking for fresh florida keys cuisine?

browse our menubrowse our photo galleryget directions and stop by fish tales market and eatery today

Fish Tales is proud to be Marathon's #1 Fmaily Owned Business!

Fish Tales Market & Eatery 2015 Hall of Fame Certificate of Excellence

Fish Tales Market and Eatery is a certified Angus Beef Seller!     Fish Tales Market and Eatery is proud to serve seafood that is fresh from Florida!

Fish Tales is Proud to Serve only the
Finest Seafood & Beef!

Fish Tales Market was voted best family run business in marathon...stop by to see why!


People love Fish Tales Market & Eatery on Yelp! Have a look!